Click Here for the Spanish Text of
this page

Spanish translations of this
website courtesy of Delina. Thank you!!
Through the years of running this website I've been
asked questions about Epidermolysis Bullosa that follow in the category
of misconceptions. People believing some things regarding this condition
that are false. This is not only from strangers, friends and family, but
from the medical community, as well as actual EB patients and parents.
I've asked other parents and patients to give me their input of what the
most common misconception about EB is that they have encountered and
that is how I came up with this page. I add to it regularly when new
misconceptions arise.
Here are the most common ones in an effort to
educate everyone about EB. Please note... I am posting most of these
questions verbatim, exactly as they were asked.
Q. Is EB caused by the parent
in any way? By their use of illegal or legal drugs? By them using too
much sweet-and-low in their coffee or anything of
sort?
A. Epidermolysis Bullosa is a GENETIC condition, much
like Down Syndrome, Cystic Fibrosis or Tourette Syndrome. The gene that
causes EB was finally found in 1993. Before then there was a lot of
speculation as stated in the question, and much fault was put on the
parents. EB per se was first written about in the late 1800s, before
then surely patients would die and nobody knew why. EB has been around
FOREVER though, because it is an equal opportunity disorder, being
equally present in ALL RACES and GENDER. Parents have absolutely
NO responsibility and are not ever to blame
over how it manifests, as it is in our genes, much like we have blue
eyes or blonde hair.
In brief, some forms
of EB, such as Recessive Dystrophic and any form of Junctional, are
indeed a gene that is recessive and it only shows up if mom AND dad are
both recessive carriers, healthy carriers. But the baby must inherit
BOTH to have the condition. If he/she only inherits one he/she will be a
healthy carrier like mom and dad. Hence two healthy carriers have a 25%
chance of having a child with EB.
Dominant
Dystrophic and Simplex are 'flukes' at conception, much like many other
conditions, such as Trisomy 18, and once the patient has it, it is then
a dominant condition, hence the patient has 50% of giving it to their
children.
Q. Can antibiotics CURE
EB?
A. EB is not an infection, it is a genetic defect. No
antibiotic could cure EB, much like an antibiotic cannot cure Cystic
Fibrosis or Down Syndrome.
Q. There must be a way to
prevent EB, isn't? What precautions can parents take?
A. Because EB is not a disease, but a genetic defect,
there is nothing that can truly be done to prevent it. In most cases,
the parents are oblivious they are even carriers, and since the DNA is
so tricky regarding this, they can't even be tested for it. In the cases
where this is a 'fluke' at conception, well, that certainly can't be
prevented.
Q. If the slightest touch hurts
the skin, how come bandages don't? I don't get what it means by
"touch" or "contact." How do EB patients lie in bed, sit down,
hugged, carried, etc?
A. The answer is two-fold, because it really depends
on the form of EB.
With
Simplex EB, indeed bandages "might" cause more harm than good. The
wounds are superficial after a slight bump, and bandages cause sweat
that can cause more blisters. This, of course, if the wound is rather
small. If a wound is large it may need to be bandaged anyway to promote
healing. In simplex, and especially with babies, a small pressure of the
skin will cause a blister, bandaging does not press the skin, hence does
not usually cause blisters.
In RDEB (Recessive Dystrophic) the blisters are
from friction, not pressure, hence the bandages actually help getting
less blisters because they act like protection against the normal
scratches and bumps that would tear up the skin immediately.
Patients can lie in bed,
but they usually have to have very soft sheets or padding of some kind.
Sitting is okay, but a lot of patients do need some extra padding on a
hard chair. Patients can be hugged gently. Patients will need to be
carried in a way that does not cause any kind of friction, absolutely
NOT under the armpit for example, and more cradled like babies, without
using hands but arms under the buttocks or legs.
Q. Do you use antibiotics all
the time to treat infections?
A. Unfortunately if the body is given too many
antibiotics all the time, such as bactroban, it can build a resistance
to it. Hence it is vital to make sure the patients develops a strong
immune system to fight infection on their own and not always rely on
antibiotics of any kind. Antibiotics should be used sparingly and only
if they are really needed to ensure that when they are indeed needed,
they will WORK!
Q. Are EB blisters like rashes,
red areas or sores of Eczema or Psoriasis patients? Is EB just perhaps a
more severe form of these conditions?
A. No. EB blisters are indeed wounds, not rashes or
sores. In the cases of RD they are second degree burn-like wounds-the
kind they hospitalize people for. Eczema and Psoriases are NEVER, EVER to be confused with EB. Even in
their extreme cases they are vastly different from EB, and never as
serious. It needs to be understood that the blisters normal people get
are not the kind of blisters that EB patients get. They are much, much
more severe. The protein that acts as a glue between the layers of skin
is not produced or not enough of, causing the skin to peel off. Leaving
2nd degree burn-like wounds on RD patients.
Q. Won't wrapping the hands
cause children with EB to be very behind for their age group with using
their hands?
A. The first thing to understand that is very
important is that it is cruel to "expect"
any child with EB with their fragile hands (and this is most especially
for those children with the more severe forms of EB) to be able to do
all the things a normal child does. I am not saying here to 'not let the
children try things' (as I was accused), what I am saying is 'do not
expect', big difference. Their little hands hurt very easily, and
they "might" (depending on severity) never be able to do even a fraction
of what healthy children can do, so, as advice to parents, it's always
suggested to throw out the window the notion that your child with severe
EB can even remotely have normal hand use and to expect your child to be
behind in this area. Having said this, things vary differently from form
to form. With the more severe forms of EB it is more important for the
child's hand to be protected and safe than worry about
development-children WILL learn to do things, adapt and develop at their
own pace and figure out a way to do things.
There will never be a need to wrap or protect the
hand of a child with a mild form of EB at all (such as DDEB, Simplex and
Junctional non-herlitz), but it is essential with severe forms, and
especially so with the disfiguring form, which is Recessive Dystrophic.
The hands of children with Recessive Dystrophic, if not wrapped, WILL
web and contract, becoming unusable or close to it as time goes on,
needing painful reconstructive hand surgeries to restore at least some
function. Hence, with RD, the wrapping serves more than protection from
wounds or covering wounds, it literally is a form of physical therapy,
because by using slight pressure the fingers are kept apart and
straight. The gauze also serves by giving the patient's fragile skin a
little more strength in pulling and pushing.
Q. Do people need to keep their
distance from EB patients so they won't catch it?
A. EB is not a disease or an illness like Chicken Pox
or HIV. It cannot be 'caught' by being close to a patient, much like you
cannot 'catch' Down Syndrome by hugging them or sharing a drink with
them. EB is a birth defect, the defect lies in the DNA, in the genes. It
is perfectly safe to hug and kiss an EB patient, EB is not
contagious.
Q. How can twins be born one
with EB and one without if EB is a genetic condition?
A. While that is true for identical twins (meaning, if
one identical twin has the condition, the other one, by virtue of the
DNA being identical, will have it as well), that is not always the case
for fraternal twins. In fraternal twins it is very possible to have
babies where one has a genetic condition like EB, and one not. Just like
one baby can be born with down syndrome, and the fraternal twin be
perfectly healthy. A recessive condition has a 25% chance of developing,
and it's a roll of the dice each pregnancy/baby.
Q. I saw on TV a show about a
child with EB who got skin grafts and she is now basically cured! Why
can't all patients get this skin graft?
A. Dateline NBC had a special in conjunction with
People Magazine about Medical Miracles in the summer 2001 which has
subsequently rerun on MSNBC on and off since then. The child that
received this treatment, Tori Cameron, was the first EB child to receive
a skin graft called Apligraf in an effort to heal her extensive wounds.
Tori suffers from the Simplex, Dowling Meara form of EB, which can be
quite severe at birth. Because she was the first patient to receive it,
and it worked in closing her wounds, she made national news and appeared
in shows such as Headline News, Extra and Dateline. Apligraf has since
been used in many patients in an effort to close their wounds.
2 things are important to know:
1. Tori's form of EB dramatically improves with age
regardless of any skin graft.
2. Apligraf only
has about a 50% success rate, but all it does is close the wound, it
does not cure EB, because skin grafts cannot alter the patient's DNA
unless they are made to do that specifically. The patient can and will
re-blister in the spot where the Apligraf was put eventually. Stanford
is working on skin grafts which are made to specifically replace the
patient's skin, and in that case they would indeed 'cure' that area
where the skin graft will be put, but the treatment is several years
away at best.
While the story on Dateline was
great in awareness, we received several emails and hundreds of hits to
this website subsequently from people erroneously thinking that if we
just put Apligraf on all EB patients, the condition will disappear. Tori
did get better, but all children with her form of EB improve
dramatically anyway in the first years of life, and even more after
puberty. Patients with other more severe forms of EB, such as Recessive
Dystrophic or Junctional, while they can benefit from the Apligraf, if
it takes, their condition will not improve at all.
Q. Does EB spontaneously
appear at 3, 4 or 5 years of age? Could it be a side-effect from
vaccinations? My girlfriend is 45. She says her EB showed up when she
was 5 years old.
A.
Patients are
definitely born with EB. EB is a genetic disorder, and to say that it
didn't "show up" until the patient was 5 years old is like saying that
the baby was born healthy and then at 5 years old all of a sudden he/she
had Down Syndrome! It just cannot be. Maybe your girlfriend was very
mild before and then something triggered it to make it worse or does not
have EB at all. No vaccination could ever cause this, unless
vaccinations can now alter the DNA. The vast majority of patient's EB is
diagnosed immediately or when it starts to show. In some babies it does
not show right away because the baby still has some of mom's good fluids
in its system. There is only one form of EB (aquisita) that all of a
sudden shows up in later years (one documented case of the patient being
in his 30s, usually it is much later, 60s+) when the body becomes weak
and stops producing enough of the protein, but that is so rare I only
have come in contact of one patient with it (and he yelled at me because
I didn't have any info on his form of EB-actually I do, it's under 'dystrophic').
Q. There must be a lotion or a
cream that can heal that right up! I bet that products for sensitive
skin would heal EB!
A. Creams and Lotions can help in the healing, but
because this is a genetic defect, they will not get rid of the condition
per se. EB cannot be cured by creams and lotions just like Sickle Cell
Disease cannot be cured this way. Genetic Conditions can't be cured with
any sort of cream unless they can alter the patient's
DNA.
Q. Why does bleach in baths
helps EB patients?
A.
Bleach Baths help
because they kill germs that cause infections. Especially those patients
with the more severe kinds. Infection is the #1 killer of EB patients.
Q. If you starve a baby long
enough, she will nurse or eat.
A.
While this might be
true for healthy children with no mouth involvement, children with EB of
any form (yes, including Simplex!) can and will blister and have raw
areas in their mouth, throat and esophagus making it extremely painful
to eat. Doctors not familiar with EB have told parents not to force
their babies to eat, that if they get hungry enough they would suck and
swallow their milk. These babies are in too much pain to actually eat,
and they can and will act hungry and will keep dropping weight. It is in
these instances that a G-tube becomes a lifesaving option. The point is,
don't starve your babies! Get help.
Q. I heard that a high protein
diet causes blisters. Since EB patients need to be on high protein
diets, could it be that that is the reason why they
blister?
A.
Patients lose so much
blood and nutrients from their wounds, they need to get high protein
from anywhere they can find. Supplements etc. Wounds can cover most of
an RD patient's body, hence the body needs to make it up somehow. No
high protein diet would ever cause any symptom that is anywhere close to
what RDEB patients endure
Q. Don't Herbs and Plant
treatments help cure
EB?
A. During the time that it was not known what caused
EB (before it became known that it is a genetic condition) patients were
often treated and maltreated, put through every herb and plant treatment
known. Nothing ever worked. Even as recently as the past couple of years
people that do care came up with their own 'plant' and herb treatments
and swore that the patients improved. Upon closer examination of
pictures of the so called improvement of the patient or description, it
became clear that the patients suffered from the Dowling Meara form of
Simplex EB, a form of EB that improves with age regardless of herb or
plant treatments of any kind. Whether herb or plant treatments can
somewhat help EB symptoms has never been fully proved, surely they can't
hurt, but it is an impossibility for these to cure EB unless they can alter the patient's
DNA.
Q. Can EB disappear, I mean,
completely disappear with age?
A. EB can't per se disappear, because the mutation
lies in the genes. EB is not a virus or a disease, it's a genetic
mutation, and the genes don't mutate by themselves. There is an
extremely rare form of EB called 'transient of the newborn' where it
does go away around the child's first birthday, but the patient's DNA is
not altered per se, the child simply had a late start on producing the
protein.
Q. There must be a typical
diet for EB patients, isn't there?
A.
There is no typical
diet for EB patients, because every patient is different. Those whose
mouth is sore with wounds can only eat usually mushy liquid fluids,
those whose throat and esophagus is damaged, they get the tube. Most
others can eat whatever they want.
Q. Why do patients get
EB?
A. ... for the same reason why you have blue eyes or
brown hair, or get Down Syndrome instead of Sickle Cell Disease, or why
some women get Breast Cancer at 30 and some at 60, and some never get
it. There is no rhyme or reason, sometimes is just bad luck, or
something in the genes that is incorrect... every human being is a
carrier of at least 7 potential gene defects lying dormant in their
system, waiting to be passed on to the next generation. Some get lucky
and don't pass it, some however...
Q. I bet there are no books
about EB.
A.
For books about EB go
to this page: http://www.ebinfoworld.com/amazon.htm
Q. Do patients recover from
EB?
A.
There is no way
anyone could ever recover from EB. Patients with the simplex form
improve in the first years of life, and then again somewhat improve
after puberty, but that's all. Think about it like this. Do your blue
eyes turn brown later in life? Nop. That is because it's in the genes.
Unless the DNA magically changes somewhat overnight or with time, it is
impossible for a patient to lose their blue eyes like it's impossible
for them to lose their EB or their Down Syndrome. As far as if the
condition gets worse or improves with age, that depends on the form.
Simplex improves with age, Recessive Dystrophic gets worse due to the
constant breakdown of the skin and severe scarring.
Q. Nobody cares about EB
because is so rare, I bet there is no one looking for a
cure.
A. Stanford is working on Gene Therapy for RDEB at the
moment with success. So is a Dr in Italy. A potential cure for the
Junctional Herlitz form is awaiting FDA approval and clinical
trials. Click
Here for the latest from Stanford.
Q. Does a skin area damaged by
the EB get deep red and sore and itch and be hot to touch at one moment,
and then maybe an hour later, be more faded, a more normal skin
temperature, and maybe just itch a little?
A.
A blister on an EB
patient is a wound. Is not a red area that an hour later is more faded.
A wound is a wound. And needs to be treated as such. On RD patients it's
actually a second degree burn-like wound.
Q. Do all EB patients have
Allergies?
A.
Not all EB patients
have allergies. It just depends if they are predisposed for it. I know
many EB patients who are not allergic to anything, it just depends on
their genetic make up like normal people.
Q. EB patients cannot be out
in the sun, right? I bet they blister in the sun.
A.
EB Patients do not
sunburn easier or faster than anyone. However, a bad sunburn would be
surely quite more painful and severe than for you and me.
Q. Why do EB parents
continuously want to do hand surgeries to their RDEB children when adult
RDEB patients say that all they want is their thumb? Why don't EB
parents listen to the adult RDEB patients?
A. A big misconception is that EB parents don't or
won't listen to adults with the condition. Nothing is further from the
truth. I am yet to meet a parent that does not take the advice from an
adult patient. When it comes to hand surgeries, the fact of the matter
is, that most adult RDEB patients were not aware of the benefits of the
wrapping until recently, and now do not have the time nor the energy to
wrap the ABC way to keep the fingers intact, and since they never did
this to begin with, they feel content to simply having a thumb. More
often than not, most patients have told me they wished their parents had
taken more care of their hands, that if their parents had taken care of
their hands like I take care of Nicky's hands, they would have hands
now... that they miss having hands... that they look at their baby
pictures in nostalgia just seeing that they had hands
once.
Both times that my son had
surgeries in his hands it was done because it was needed. On the right
hand it was done when he was 2, and thanks to the ABC wrapping my son, 6
years later, still has fingers. Nobody can ever convince me that the
combo surgery/abc wrapping is something wrong to do to my child. When he
was two he would not even use that hand, and he is right handed. Now he
uses it every day. The left hand was so gone by the time Nicky was 5
that he had no fingers left, they were incased in his palm. It was my
son's decision to have the surgery, and now that he has a hand he's
happy he's done the surgery when he did. If a 7 year old is happy about
HIS decision, who is anyone to judge and criticize me? Unfortunately I
get criticized for this all the time. Sigh. My take on this is... I make
my son make the decisions, if he's happy with it, I am happy
too.
Q. Why do patients die of
EB?
A.
EB patients don't die
from EB. They die of infections, anemia, organs that are weak because of
lack of nutrition or skin cancer. All of these are side-effects of EB.
Q. Are all forms of EB considered
'Lethal'?
A.
Any condition that is
labeled 'LETHAL' (also known as TERMINAL) implies that, upon diagnose,
the patient will
die from the condition sooner or later. The only two forms of EB
that are considered LETHAL are Junctional-Herlitz and other Junctional
forms (such as Pyloric Atresia) and RDEB. Junctional babies usually die
before their first birthday, while RDEB patients live a painful life
that can range from 0-30 years in most cases, although there have been
patients that have lived longer. The causes vary, usually ranging from
severe Anemia, Infection and Skin Cancer. Yes, other forms of EB 'can'
be lethal too, but not by definition, as in the vast majority of cases
the patient has a normal life span. Some old textbooks and Doctors will
say that babies born with a rather severe form of EB Simplex called
Dowling Meara have a 25% chance of dying their first year of life, but
the validity of that statement has become questionable in recent years
due to advances of antibiotics and wound care. The National EB Registry
lists EBS-DM patients as having only a 1.44% chance of dying at any age.
The link to
that page is here.
Q. Why are parents so hung up
on a cure?
A. EB parents are NOT hung up on a cure. Yet this is
what most adult patients think when the subject is brought up about the
advances in gene therapy and stuff. Yes, we like to keep informed and
see where the research is going, that does not mean we are "hung up" on
a cure. We are accused of giving false hopes to our children when every
parent I know has never promised such things to our children. We
are accused of just being awful when all we need, as parents of children
with a lethal condition is just a little hope. Read my column about Hope
here.
Q. I was told 15, 20, 25, 30,
35 (or more) years ago that a cure was just a few years away. I think
the best thing for parents to do is not to put their hopes up on a cure
because a cure will most likely not going to happen anytime soon and in
their lifetime, since it hasn't happened in all these
years.
A.
It was SO INCREDIBLY
WRONG for doctors to tell parents/patients all these years ago, that a
cure was coming. Actually, I get pretty angry when I hear of any parent
that was told a cure was coming in 'just a few years' back in the 60s,
70s and 80s. Let me tell you why:
1. The gene that causes EB was not discovered until
1993. Yes, 1993!!!! How can anyone be
looking for a cure, if they didn't even know what gene caused the
disorder? It makes no sense whatsoever.
2. The EBMRF, which is the sole monetary
contributor to EB Research at Stanford, was only founded in 1991, there
was no 'real' EB research done before then. When we took Nicky to
Stanford and we talked to Dr. Marinkovich in early 1998, he stated to me
quite clearly that at the moment they were not doing ANY research on
RDEB at all, they were concentrating on Junctional. Real research for
RDEB did not truly start until 1999/2000, so in all true senses, the
real research for a cure for RDEB has only truly been worked on for 4-5
years at the very most. Anyone that tells you they worked on it before
then they were... yes, lying.
I also get frustrated when people tell me "not to
put my hopes up", because the only thing that keeps me smiling at my
child on bad days, is the 'hope' that maybe, someday, something,
anything, might help his condition. I am not even hoping for a full
blown a cure at this point, just a way to ease it up a bit. Hope is what
is all about, what makes me go from today to tomorrow at times. I even
wrote a column about hope:
http://www.sleepingangel.com/smc_sep02.htm#hope
Q. All EB patients can die of
Cancer?
A.
Yes and No, it
depends on the form. While there is only a minute chance of Simplex
patients to develop Cancer (1 in 100 in their lifetime), with RDEB
patients, in most cases, it is unfortunately not a matter of IF, but a
matter of WHEN.
I found this very interesting
page with Cancer in EB patients statistics you might want to check out:
http://www.med.unc.edu/derm/nebr_site/cancer.htm
Basically, up to age 40, there are virtually NO
instances of SCC (Squamous Cell Carcinoma) for EB patients unless they
have RDEB. RDEB patients have a 6% chance of getting SCC at 20 years of
age, 21% chance at 25 years of age, nearly 40% at 30 and 53% at 35. Even
at 60 years of age, Junctional patients have never been reported
statistically as getting SCC at all, simplex patients only have a minute
chance of getting SCC, barely over 1%, DDEB patients almost 4% at 60
years age, but, in contrast, a 76% chance for RDEB patients.
As far as Malignant Melanoma, this is actually
fairly rare to get, barely 1-2% by 55 years of age with all forms of EB
except for Junctional, with a 0% instance.
For
Basal Cell Carcinoma, they state that by 40 years of age < 1% of all
patients with EB simplex and DDEB have experienced a BCC, higher with
RDEB, with 4%.
Q. What is the medical
explanation for some people with EB living to be 72 and others maybe
only 10?
A. One word: severity. The patient that dies at 72 age
has a much milder form of the condition than the 10 year old. It is also
true that perhaps the 72 year old was much better cared for than the 10
year old. Perhaps the parents of the 10 year old were living in a poor
country or were not aware of how to properly care for their child. It is
all up for debate, however, in most cases, it is a case of
severity.
Q. Do all EB patients have to
have a G-tube?
A.
Again, this depends
on the form and severity of their form. Simplex
rarely has problems in the mouth, but IT DOES
HAPPEN! Most if not all Recessive Dystrophic patients, however,
can and will blister everywhere... lips, tongue, gums, mouth, throat
esophagus. Some patients may be able to eat enough by mouth (which is
then usually mushy or liquid foods) and others cannot, that is why those
patients might end up with a Gtube.
Q. I believe mouth blisters
might not be from having EB, but from the dental fluoride treatment or
the toothpaste with fluoride, or the children's multivitamin with
fluoride, etc. Which the parent thinks is good for the
child!
A. Fluoride could never cause the damage to EB
children's mouths that I have witnessed. If so, any child with fluoride
treatments would have their gums webbed, tongue adhered to the bottom of
the mouth, and scarring in the esophagus, which, as we know, does not
happen. Nicky was not on fluoride treatments when his mouth blistering
started (at birth) and is not now, although he should, and he still
blisters badly.
Q. I think that if EB patients
could get laser treatments to 'burn the scars off', healthy skin would
grow underneath!
A. I myself do not even know if the above statement
would even work on a healthy patient, but even if it was true, and, for
conversation's sake, let's say it is true and the scars would 'burn off'
and healthy skin would grow underneath on a healthy patient and it was
tried on an EB patient, even if the treatment would work, which is
highly unlikely to begin with, the patient would still have EB after all
is said and done. He/she would still get blisters and still scar. This
is because EB is a genetic defect, and no laser treatment can cure EB
unless it can magically alter the DNA of the EB
patient.
Q. Instead of wrapping these
children from head to toe, isn't better to dry out the
wounds?
A. While that is possibly the preferred method with
most children with simplex, very mild dystrophic and even some
junctional non-herlitz patients, simply because the wounds are
superficial and don't normally scar because they lie within the
epidermis, or the wounds are few, letting the wounds dry with moderate
to severe Dystrophic patients means they will scar and also cause
deformities in the extremities. Wounds can also develop infections if
air dried, and it has been observed that moderate to severe children
with RD that are never wrapped have a much shorter life span because
most of their little bodies are covered with scars. A scar is weak skin
that can brake down much easier than an area that was properly healed,
hence these children develop huge areas of weak skin that once breaks
down will be open forever and have a high chance of developing nasty
infections and even become cancerous in later years.
Bandages for RD patients serve many purposes: They
allow for proper healing of wounds, they protect the healthy skin from
braking down in the first place, and they allow the patient to do much
more than without it. Most patients could not even walk without bandages
on their feet. In areas where a bandage cannot be put, it is strongly
recommended to keep the area moist by applying either zinc oxide 40% or
Aquafor or any ointment twice a day to allow moisture to penetrate the
wound and heal it properly.
Q. You publicly announced that
you think unwrapping a child with RDEB borders on child abuse. You are
entitled to your opinion - but what if you are wrong? What if there are
other children out there who could benefit from
unwrapping?
A. The person that wrote this to yours truly (your
humble webmaster) took things out of context for one, and for two, I
never 'publicly' announced anything, this was part of a discussion. For
starters, my actual statement was that unwrapping a severe RDEB child borders on child
abuse. There is a big difference between mild to
moderate RDEB patients and severe
patients. This is not an 'opinion' as she implies, it is something
substantiated by not only the Debra Nurse, but Wound Care Specialists,
Burn Unit Doctors and Nurses.
RDEB wounds are 2nd degree burn-like wounds, they
are not superficial. If healed without moisture they can and will scar,
and will be prone to infections. Since infection is the #1 killer of EB
patients, you can see why making sure wounds are protected and healed
skin is covered to prevent new wounds important, and why leaving a child
with these types of wounds unbandaged is simply unthinkable and, yes,
bordering on child abuse. There was a case of two little boys with severe RDEB left
unbandaged who were on the brink of death from infections and were taken
away from the parents and given to a loving foster family who wrapped
them and... they thrived! Think I am making this up? Their story is
here. RDEB patients who are not as severe do not blister as
easily. There is a mother who claims her child is 'severe' because she
was given an RDEB-HS diagnose, that may be so, but there are differences
of severity within each type, and since she posted pictures of her
daughter with only a swimsuit on and no wounds in sight, there is no way
she can ever convince me her child is severe. My son Nicky has never,
ever had his body wound free in his whole life, he has wounds that
haven't healed in years, and on his best days his wounds account to at
least 30% of his body. It's important to remember that the more severe
the patient is, the easier it is to get a wound, that's why protection
from normal bumps and scratches from every day life is important for
these severe
patients. These patients do not benefit at all from unwrapping, as the
area unbandaged is extremely easy to hurt.
But,
once again, this is not my "opinion". Why take my word for it?
Click on the following link to read more on why
bandaging severe
RDEB patients is vital:
-DebRA's Skin Care and Bandaging
Page
Q. Aren't EB parents way
overprotecting of their children?
A. Being "overprotective" is a gripe all children
have, healthy or not. This is something, however, that children do end
up understanding about their parents once the children become parents
themselves. It is impossible to understand otherwise. I (the webmaster)
for example, was never, ever allowed to have a sleep over growing up. Of
course, at the time I thought my parents were 'way' overprotective, but
since I've had children of my own, I've come to totally understand my
parent's reasonings about this and other matters.
EB patients that are not parents often complain to
EB parents about this... One time I was called 'evil' by an EB
patient because I was taking precautions so my very severe and fragile
EB child would not get hurt in kindergarten. None of my explanations to
her how 4 and 5 years olds like to push, pull, kick, pinch, throw, step
on and run into people, made her understand my point, a point that was
backed up by my son's teacher, his aide, the school's nurse, the
principal and it was even written in my son's IEP. Basically I told the
kids on the first day at school that Nicky's skin was extremely fragile
and they could not touch him unless it was to hug him. Now that Nicky's
in third grade, my talk to the 8 and 9 year olds is quite different. I
don't have to tell them not to touch him, because they understand when I
tell them he's fragile and they don't feel like their kindergarten
counterparts that they can kick him just a little bit, or push him just
a little bit, they understand that fragile means fragile. Period.
We know our children like no one else can, and now
that Nicky is old enough I ask for his opinion on things to be done to
or for him 100% of the time. If he gives me the green light for
something, I am certainly not going to subscribe to be called evil by
anyone if they do not agree. Especially by someone who is not a
parent.
Q. People treat us (EB people)
like we are so bad off & like we are paper and get hurt just by
thinking about things to do... I bet my life that if we had people
treating him (referring to a very severe RDEB patient) like everyone
else.. like playing sports & doing what most kids do he wouldn't be
so worse off right now.. I bet my life on
that!!
A. Severe RDEB children already have 50% or more open
wounds on their bodies, and can barely walk nor WANT or CAN play
basketball or any type of sport, how can anyone 'assume' they could be
better off by doing these things it's totally ridiculous. If anything,
instead of having 50% of their bodies covered in open wounds, it would
be much worse, 75-90%. If my son (who is 7 at the time I am
writing this) was inclined to want to try sports, I would not stop him,
but he has even refused a bicycle with training wheels and it took me a
week to convince him that trying a tricycle would be fun!
To assume that parents don't treat or try to treat
their kids as normal as possible is just plain rude, and, I am sorry to
say, quite ignorant at the painful life these children lead and how
fragile they really are.
Q. Is it common for those with
RDEB to need diapers? If so may I ask the cause??
A. Many parents of severe RDEB children have many
issues regarding toileting, and my Nicky is no different. Many children
just can't walk to the toilet and/or may not be able to take their
underwear down if they tried due to wounds on their hands or
deformities. Others can't sit on the toilet due to many wounds on their
bottom, others yet (and this is my son's problem) hold it in constantly
because they are afraid of skin tearing in the anus. This is a
psychological issue that many children with this problem have, and it
may not be until they are almost teenagers that they can solve it,
because they have to want to solve it themselves. No trying talks or
bribes truly work. Children that get accustomed with holding poop in end
up leaking poop all day long which makes it impossible for them to wear
any underwear. The only way they'll go is if enough laxatives are given
so they have no choice but go because it's basically liquid, which makes
it even more impossible for them to wear underwear. The fact that RDEB
children are anemic and we have to give them iron does not help either,
since iron constipates. It's a losing battle and for many severe RDEB
children diapers are the only answer...
Q. Why do some RDEB patients require
blood transfusions and why are family Drs suggesting to have this done?
In what ways does it help??
A. My Nicky's pediatrician referred him to a hematologist
because Nicky had no energy and he had been severely anemic for a very
long time. Nicky's hematologist is Dr. Coates, which spoke at the
conference about EBers problems related to anemia. He is not only an
expert hematologist, he is an expert in hematology and how it relates to
EB.
Nicky's blood
count has been dangerously low for a long time, but recently were below
borderline. Having a very low count means he's extremely anemic, which
means that Nicky's life is in danger if nothing is done. A blood
transfusion gives him some iron-rich blood plus trasferrin (sp?) which
he is also missing. Transferrin is something the blood needs to have to
absorb iron in foods and supplements and that somehow many severe RDEB
patients lose after several years of bleeding through the wounds. After
a couple of blood transfusions he started iron-transfusions which work
better since his blood now has the trasferrin which enables his
blood to absorb the iron.
Most RDEBers have this problem and a few children
have even died because of it...
Q. For those w/ spontaneous mutations for
the first time in the family, I am not totally convinced it isn't
something in the environment. I understand that the recessive types
occur when two people carry the gene and if you have a dominant type and
pass that on as well... but I still don't understand how it could just
occur out of the blue...?? Especially when there are other types out
there you have to have/carry for your child to have it and its called
the same thing? Are the other conditions that can occur spontaneously as
well?
A. There are a lot of conditions out there that are
'flukes' at conception, so many things can go wrong during conception I
often wonder the wonder of nature of how many people are actually born
healthy to be honest! LOL. But... I digress...
A few years ago there was
a group of Vietnam Vets that contacted me because many of them had
children with Simplex, which as we know, it's a dominant condition and a
fluke at conception. They thought there was something to it. We went
back and forth for a while, and we never came back to a conclusion. It
is possible.
As
per your question regarding how a condition that is a fluke at
conception/dominant can be associated to a recessive condition that
someone carries... the answer is actually quite simple. It's because of
the nature of the beast. Even though they are two different beasts, they
are associated because the symptoms are similar: Blistering. You have to
remember that the word EB is just an 'umbrella' for various blistering
conditions, something Doctors associated more than a hundred years ago.
We often speak how Simplex is vastly different from Dystrophic and how
Dystrophic is vastly different from Junctional etcetera, so different
that they are treated quite different and the same type of products do
not work from one form to another. They should not be listed with the
same name (EB), but they are because it was something done before they
even knew of all the differences. The word EB per se means the
blistering of the epidermis, and if you think about it, it doesn't
really fit the dystrophic forms because the blistering forms in the
dermis, not in the epidermis! But, again at the time EB was named and
all the forms associated, they weren't even aware of any differences,
and now it's too late to change it!
Q. I saw a documentary about a man with
EB and the narrator stated that he never went through puberty. Why is
that? What causes it? Is this a common problem with EB
patients?
A. It's important to understand that going through
puberty requires a lot of calories and nutrition. In general, people who
do not have much food to eat or are unable to eat much will have a
delayed puberty or will not go through puberty at all, and this is the
main reason why RDEB patients sometimes do not go through this stage of
life. Why is that? RDEB patients have a scarred and strictured
esophagus, and eating is always a big problem in general due to the
mouth and throat being prone to easy blistering and painful sores. This
is not the case for Simplex or Junctional patients, as their mouth,
throat and esophagus is not normally damaged nor CAN get damaged to the
extent that they cannot eat enough to sustain them. However, it is a
HUGE problem for RDEB patients. My son Nicky, who is 8.5 years old as I
write this, most likely would not be alive today without his g-tube and
his constant throat dilatations to enlarge his esophagus that has been
so closed up, the passing was only 1mm large. Because of the g-tube
feedings now he is as big as a normal 8.5 year old would be and will
most likely go through puberty without any problems. G-tubes have only
been around for the past 15-20 years or so.
Q. I noticed that RDEB
patients seem to have a discoloration of the skin. Why is
that?
A. The skin is not really discolored. Most RDEB
patients are very anemic due to the heavy loss of blood through their
wounds, and lack of iron in anyone's blood will make the skin look very
pale.
Q. Does EB effect the teeth, and if so,
how? Does it affect the gums? I was looking at a picture of a
child with RDEB (Nicky) and noticed that the teeth looked
different.
A. While some forms of EB (namely, Junctional) do
effect the teeth, the form of EB Nicky has (RDEB) does not effect his
teeth per se. However, the problem arises in the fact that he cannot
brush his teeth like normal human beings. Brushing his teeth like we do
will cause the skin of his gums to fall off and would be excruciatingly
painful. That is why many RDEB patients do lose all their teeth
eventually, simply because of the inability to clean them properly.
Mouthwashes and other methods have worked a little, but never
fully.
Q. I am reading a site called debra
something or other. It says that eb is in the genes. Since I guess, most
people that have this, know it, because it shows up right? It's not
dormant, right? Why do you have children instead of
adopting?
A. EB may be genetic, but that does not mean that all
parents have the condition, nor that they automatically know they are
carriers, as there is no such test.
For
those who have the dominant forms of EB, which are those forms (any form
of Simplex and Dominant Dystrophic to be specific) where the parent has
the condition (but not always-in certain cases the baby is a spontaneous
mutation), the chances of the parent to give their condition to their
child is 50/50. Since both the Simplex and Dominant Dystrophic forms of
EB are, for the most part, milder than the Recessive forms, the choice
to have a child and the chance of the child having the condition, is
usually a very personal one. Many parents have stated that their quality
of life was not greatly effected by the EB. Some with the Simplex forms
know that their children will improve greatly with age, so they find
solace in that.
For those who have
children with the recessive forms of EB, they do not have the condition,
but they are carriers. There is no 'test' to find out if we are
carriers, and they are none the wiser, as I was. The only way a child is
born with a recessive form of EB (any form of Junctional and Recessive
Dystrophic to be specific) is if *both* parents are healthy carriers.
The birth of their child with EB is always a *surprise*. Two healthy
carriers have a 25% chance of having a child with EB. Since these
children are usually quite severe, and many die as babies, these parents
for the most part do not chance another pregnancy, but now and again,
very few do. Why? Most I've known are thinking that a 75% chance of
having a healthy baby are very good odds, but, again, this is more the
exception than the rule. Most parents that have another baby is by pure
mistake, not by choice.
Why not adopt? As many
people that know me personally would tell you, my long time dream is do
adopt a little girl from those nasty orphanages in China. But, like an
old Italian saying goes... "Between the 'saying'
and the 'doing' there is an ocean in between", and this time is for
real. I simply do not have the money, and many people have my same
problem. Adoption is a very expensive option, one that many simply
cannot afford.
More Questions and Answers that were sent to
us.
Q. Is it the type of shoes you
wear that causes the blisters?
A.
No, I can get the
blisters while going barefooted. I have the Localized Simplex
Weber-cockayne disorder. I get this question all of the time. ~Cindy
Q. I was scarred from burns
all over my body. I went to a herbal doctor, and got on an herbal diet,
and now my wounds are healed and I have little or no scarring. Can't you
do that for your son who has DDEB?
A.
This question was
asked to me by someone in a courthouse who happened to see my son's DDEB
from down the hall. Although herbal medicine, may help a little, it will
not cure EB. Herbal medicine cannot change your genes. Since EB is a
genetic defect, herbal medicine may help with healing, but will never
CURE EB. ~Dawn

EB Info World fully supports
EBAN's mission
